I was initially extremely impressed by the precision of the memories of the class when I taught a unit on the presidential speeches from the period immediately following September 11th. Four months later the class seemed to remember each vocal inflection, nuance of tone, stammer, hesitation over a word, and emotive pause. I had treated the president's speeches as works that were conventional genre pieces, but it seemed as if the performance of these speeches still resonated with undergraduates months later.

As we studied what had seemed to me to be lifeless scripts from the official White House web site, they commented on both throat catching and throat clearing moments as though the discrete experiences of hearing them on television or the radio were still vivid. The mystery was solved when my web-savvy class pointed out that I could easily click "Listen to the President's Remarks" or "View the President's Remarks" simply by clicking on the silhouette of a speaker or television screen. They had no need to recall oratory that was instantaneously available on playback.