We should consider how we talk about computers
Franklin Becker suggests in Workspace:
Creating Environments in Organizations, (Praeger, 1981), that an
environment operates at several levels simulatenously. Inspired by
this distinction, I would
suggest that computers operate at at least three levels:
- Computers operate as tools located within the
larger "walk-in" writing center itself. The computer can be a tool
located on desks, a tool that helps us design, compose and format
texts for print or on-line distribution. It can be a tool that helps
us store and organize data.
- Computers can operate as environments. If we shift our
focus from the computer as a tool to the computer as an environment
all its own, an environment created by the configuration of hardware
and interface, then we can talk about a computer as a virtual space,
an space into which we project ourselves. Just as the
traditional writing center creates a space in which tutors and
students work, so can a computer interface create a virtual
environment in which students can work & interact. We can think,
therefore, about Building
Learning Spaces on the Internet.
- Finally, computers can operate as a medium that presents
tools in a particular environment. A given computer can offer a space
filled with tools and symbols, thereby creating a medium through which
one reads and writes (both simultaneously and over time), a medium
that delivers and presents information in a way unique from other
media. Consequently, each application of computer technology creates
a medium that, through the arrangement of tools and space, enables
certain practices while suppressing others.
Just as we need to consider what theories inform
any discussion of technology, we also need to know at what level
people are talking about technology. Otherwise, I fear that
participants in a discussion on this issue could simply talk past one
another.
Stuart Blythe
Purdue University
blythes@mace.cc.purdue.edu